Risorse · 40
Valutare i segnali di social listening prima di agire.
Separare volume, origini, repost e fatti verificati per indirizzare i casi utili.
Aggiornato · 6 min
Obiettivi di questa guida
- Descrivere la raccolta
- Eliminare i duplicati
- Verifica dei fatti
- Instradare e chiudere
Verifica rapida
- Quali fonti e lingue mancano?
- Le menzioni sono indipendenti o repost?
- Cosa sappiamo oltre al post?
- Quale effetto concreto giustifica un'escalation?
- La risoluzione è stata confermata?
Metodo passo passo
- 1
Definire la domanda
Specificare la decisione, i temi, le piattaforme, le lingue, il periodo e i limiti di raccolta. Non considerare i partecipanti online come una popolazione rappresentativa.
Risultato: protocollo e copertura dichiarata.
- 2
Conservare la provenienza
Registrare il link, la data, il contesto visibile e il metodo di individuazione per ogni segnalazione. Conservare solo i dati personali necessari per la gestione.
Risultato: registrazione della segnalazione con data.
- 3
Eliminare i duplicati
Raggruppare citazioni, copie, screenshot e post successivi relativi allo stesso evento. Separare il volume di distribuzione dai casi indipendenti.
Risultato: cronologia e cluster di origine.
- 4
Verificare le affermazioni
Ricercare fonti primarie, contesto e prove contrarie. Contrassegnare ciò che è confermato, plausibile o sconosciuto senza dedurre l'intento da un singolo post.
Risultato: stato dei fatti e livello di attendibilità.
- 5
Instradare in base all'effetto
Applicare criteri di gravità e assegnare reclami, rischi per la sicurezza o voci al team competente. Redigere risposte che distinguano i fatti dalle indagini in corso.
Risultato: responsabile, tempistica e decisione.
- 6
Chiudere e imparare
Confermare l'esito, correggere le dichiarazioni pubbliche ove necessario e perfezionare i termini di ricerca e le regole di triage. Confrontare i casi risolti, non solo le menzioni.
Risultato: chiusura e revisione del metodo.
Indicatori di gestione
| Indicatore | Cosa misura | Prima azione |
|---|---|---|
| Copertura | Fonti e lingue effettivamente osservate | Segnalazione di punti ciechi |
| Deduplicazione | Casi distinti per cluster di repost | Evitare il doppio conteggio |
| Qualificazione | Casi con fatti e affidabilità | Estensione della verifica |
| Risoluzione | Casi escalati effettivamente chiusi | Revisione della proprietà e della tempistica |
Errori comuni
- Trattare le menzioni come opinioni rappresentative
- Contare ogni copia come un nuovo incidente
- Pubblicare le conclusioni prima della verifica
- Conservare dati personali non necessari
Domande frequenti
Un picco di menzioni dimostra una crisi?
No. Può derivare da una campagna, da una raccolta modificata o dalla ripetizione di un messaggio.
Ogni segnale deve ricevere una risposta?
Dipende dall'impatto, dalla verifica, dal canale e dal rischio di amplificazione.
Come si dovrebbe rappresentare l'incertezza?
Separare i fatti osservati, le ipotesi e le informazioni ancora da ricercare.
Catene di citazioni e ascolto sociale
Le note dettagliate di questa edizione sono disponibili in inglese.
Useful social listening explains what circulates, which records support a claim and which decision needs preparation. Ten reposts of one document do not become ten confirmations. This dossier adds a way to read documentary dependencies and a briefing structure for OSINT monitoring, reputation and crisis communication.
Official reference: RESIST 3, published 29 October 2025. CIE applications, cases and workshop rules are educational material, not an official RESIST tool or a disinformation diagnosis.
Government Communications · RESIST 3 · RESIST 3 · 2025 · consulted 2026-10-23
Six stages from a signal to a reviewed decision
| RESIST 3 stage | Short reference | Original practical application |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Recognise Recognise | Separate checkable information, opinion and missing context. | CIE application: retain the exact question to be checked before classifying content. Strong criticism does not establish manipulation. |
| 2. Early warning Early warning | Organise monitoring around defined risks. | CIE application: record time window, channels, languages, queries and exclusions. Compare like-for-like periods and document collection outages. |
| 3. Situational insight Situational insight | Turn observations into decision-relevant information. | CIE application: separate message counts, cited documents and observed effects. Identify the question that remains unanswered. |
| 4. Impact analysis Impact analysis | Prioritise consequences and uncertainties. | CIE application: name the exposed service, owner and next review. A rise in reposts alone cannot quantify harm. |
| 5. Strategic communications Strategic communications | Choose a proportionate response or monitor without responding. | CIE application: specify the audience to help, useful fact and suitable channel. Consider whether a public response would increase the content’s visibility. |
| 6. Tracking effectiveness Tracking effectiveness | Evaluate communication and the response process. | CIE application: define an observable outcome before action, then record what actually changes and what remains unknown. Clicks and resolution are different measures. |
ABCDE: prepare a briefing without filling unknowns
| Field | Question to document | Pitfall to avoid |
|---|---|---|
| Actor | Which accounts or organisations are actually identified? | Inferring nationality, intent or coordination from tone. |
| Behaviour | Which actions were observed, and when? | Turning timing similarity into proof of coordination. |
| Content | Which exact claim and document version? | Treating a headline, cropped image and full text as equivalent records. |
| Degree | What spread was measured, within which scope? | Presenting mentions as unique people or representative opinion. |
| Effect | What effect was observed, and on whom? | Conflating possible effect, observed harm and established causation. |
Government Communications · RESIST 3 quick reference · RESIST 3 · 2025 · consulted 2026-10-23
Seguire i riferimenti
Choose a small fictional network. An arrow “A → B” means only that A cites B. The workshop follows references reachable from the selected record and shows declared source documents, relays, missing references and cycles. Changing the starting record shows why reading scope matters.
Local calculation on eight closed datasets: no social media collection, transmission, storage or download. “Source” means a declared leaf in the exercise, without external verification. Two distinct identifiers establish neither independence, corroboration nor truth. The result measures neither real audience, a campaign nor an actor’s intent. Displayed loops are those encountered during traversal, not an exhaustive inventory of every possible cycle.
Risultato
Eight documented readings, available without JavaScript
S01 · Three relays, one document
Documento iniziale : D
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Relay | A |
| C | Relay | A |
| D | Relay | B, C |
D reaches three relays and one leaf A. B and C are not two additional confirmations.
S02 · Two declared documents
Documento iniziale : C
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Declared source | — |
| C | Relay | A, B |
Two leaves are declared. Their independence and agreement on a particular claim would still require examination of the actual documents.
S03 · Shared origin behind two intermediaries
Documento iniziale : D
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Relay | A |
| C | Relay | A |
| D | Relay | B, C, A |
Three paths reach A. The workshop deduplicates the identifier rather than counting each path as a new source.
S04 · A missing reference
Documento iniziale : B
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Relay | A, X |
A is present, X is absent from the dataset. This does not establish that X is false or nonexistent; it records a reading limitation.
S05 · Two relays cite each other
Documento iniziale : A
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Relay | B |
| B | Relay | A |
The A → B → A cycle provides no declared leaf. Circular repetition does not resolve origin.
S06 · One leaf and a cycle
Documento iniziale : B
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Relay | A, C |
| C | Relay | B |
One leaf A is reachable alongside the B ↔ C cycle. A’s presence does not remove the circular dependency.
S07 · An undocumented origin
Documento iniziale : B
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Unknown origin | — |
| B | Relay | A |
A is not declared a source: its origin is unknown. A record without citations must not automatically be promoted to an originating source.
S08 · The starting record changes scope
Documento iniziale : B
| Fictional record | Declared type | Cites records |
|---|---|---|
| A | Declared source | — |
| B | Relay | A, A |
| C | Relay | Z |
| D | Unknown origin | — |
From B, only B and A are reachable despite the repeated A reference. C and D stay outside the traversal. Selecting C reveals missing reference Z.
Checks before circulating a monitoring brief
| Check | Expected record |
|---|---|
| Scope | Period, time zone, channels, languages and coverage limits. |
| Counting unit | Distinguish messages, observed accounts, documents, interactions and people. |
| Dependency | Trace citations and keep unknown origins unknown. |
| Version | Compare publication time, collection time and the version actually read. |
| Alternative hypothesis | Check editorial reuse, mistakes or a different context before attribution. |
| Decision | Name the action, owner, deadline and new evidence that would change the brief. |
For an actionable brief, keep three statements separate: what was observed, what was inferred and what is missing. Link each inference to its records and limitation. Monitoring without a public response can be an explicit decision; give it an owner and a review deadline.
Sources, editions and credits
Original CIE summaries informed by Government Communications, RESIST 3 (2025) and its quick reference. English headings help locate official sections. No institutional logo, diagram or photograph is reproduced. Graph examples are fictional and describe no real person or operation.
Government Communications · RESIST 3 · RESIST 3 · 2025 · consulted 2026-10-23
SHA-256 : 014c25d96b2538b056541179fee24adb086770c8bdf9e382eff055279f01756b
Government Communications · RESIST 3 quick reference · RESIST 3 · 2025 · consulted 2026-10-23
SHA-256 : a27c918181a50443826fb5eb9c140741a0c53fcc4291cc45f4f3d975d82133b1
Riferimenti ufficiali
I riferimenti supportano il metodo. Adattare i controlli al proprio contesto; non costituiscono una certificazione. I titoli dei riferimenti originali e i documenti di origine potrebbero essere in un'altra lingua.
Riferimenti consultati il .
